iTaggit - The Place for Every Thing
Why Join iTaggit?
Take an inventory of your items, find their value, share them if you want, and sell them when you're ready.
Learn More
Gallery
in  


 

Comics


Problem Comics: The Red Star: Sword of Lies #3 RSS

Total Views: 760 Blog Rating:
I remember reading the original Red Star trade paperback collection years ago; if I recall correctly, it was published then by Image Comics. It's not anymore, now it's published by Archangel Studios, which both forgets to put a price anywhere on this comic book, and lists the publisher's city of residence in the indicia as "North Hollywood, Clifornia." (No one proofreads most comic books anymore.)

Because this is the third issue of a series apparently recounting "the origin story of the Red Star saga," I am late to the proceedings, having not read anything since that initial collection many years ago. I remember that it contained many full-page images of people and machinery, the people shouting, or grim, and the machinery large. Having read this new issue, I recall now that at least some of the machines use human souls as fuel.

This latest issue is a good example of how not to do comics in the era of the ascendant graphic novel. As readers increasingly wants complete stories bound up in a real book with a spine (i.e., graphic novels vs. floppy monthly-style comic "books"), it behooves those who continue to publish "floppies" to make sure that the story within a single issue is both comprehensible and satisfying as a story. It can be part of a larger tapestry, but it shouldn't alienate readers who didn't pick up the previous issue. Red Star: Sword of Lies #3 is alienation from beginning to end, incomprehensible, unexplained events affecting unknown and unknowable characters in ways we never even begin to care about.

Coming in to the universe of The Red Star this late in the game, with little interest in the previously established stories and even less in the origin of how they got there, I have to confess that clearly The Red Star: Sword of Lies #3 is not the funnybook for me. Like someone with no interest or background in Freemasonry walking into a ceremony for experienced devotees of that tradition, I have no idea what is happening and can only note that everyone involved seems very committed to their work, although no one seems to be devoting any time whatsoever to making sure outsiders can understand or appreciate what is going on.

The Red Star seems to be some sort of sci-fi pastiche/homage to the days of the Soviet Union. I have no idea if prime mover Christian Gossett was born there, or if his family is from there, or if he just thinks soviet-style costumes and saying "Komrade" a lot are just super-cool. From the available evidence, it could be any of those things, but there's so little to go on that I am forced to guess. I am sure one could craft brilliant historical fiction or historically-informed science fiction based in some way on the events or legends of Eastern Europe and its peoples. The Red Star: Sword of Lies in no way reflects that possibility. I apologize if Mr. Gossett has a genuine, profound and/or personal interest in the Soviet era, its people or symbols. If he does, I wish any of that translated to these comic books, which seem overblown, self-important, impenetrable, and deadly dull.

Published Monday, August 11, 2008 9:56 AM by alandaviddoane  

Comments

 

jarrett2512 said:

Hi, am searching for a little assistance. I recently received a relatives prized comic book collection and trying to learn how to discover the value of each book. Some of them are pretty early editions of the x-men, avengers, hulk, fantastic four... like in the teens and back. No 1st editions or anything like that. Is their a published price guide for that covers these books?

August 11, 2008 10:10 PM
 

alandaviddoane said:

Please see my article <a href="http://www.itaggit.com/community/blogs/comics/archive/2008/04/30/How-Much-Are-My-Comics-Worth_3F00_.aspx">How Much Are My Comics Worth</a>, that should give you the information you need.

August 12, 2008 5:00 AM

Anonymous comments are disabled

About alandaviddoane

I'm Alan David Doane, husband and father of two. I've been a radio broadcaster since 1985 and a writer about comics and graphic novels since the mid-1990s. I created and maintain the website Comic Book Galaxy, which first debuted 1 September 2000, and I have written The ADD Blog for Comic Book Galaxy since 2002. I am also a contributing writer for The Comics Journal, and the former reviews editor for Silver Bullet Comic Books (now Comics Bulletin). I've also contributed editorial material for Alan Moore's Yuggoth Cultures collection from Avatar Press and consulted with other creators and publishers on a number of projects. See more of my iTaggit blog posts.